The Answer's At The End

By Lisa N. Collins

San Francisco Examiner, Thursday, August 10, 1967

FLOWER CHILDREN, BEATLE GEORGE & WIFE PATTIE

How does it feel to be one of the beautiful people?

Beatle George Harrison and wife Pattie Boyd were seen among the crowd of flower children at Golden Gate Park in San Francisco Monday afternoon.   George and Pattie flew in from Los Angeles by private jet and wended their way through the crowd up Hippie Hill.  The Beatle regaled the audience with a bit from "Baby, You're a Rich Man," much to the crowd's delight.  When he refused to play more songs, the crowd converged upon the pair as they fled and sped into a waiting car.  The impromptu Beatle performance lasted little more than a few minutes. 

The pair spent several days in California visiting Pattie's sister, Jenny in Los Angeles.  George and Pattie blended to a certain extent among their young audience, with their brightly patterned clothing, buttons and beads.  George was seen wearing a flower button, much the au courant symbol of the times.

***

Many is the time I have pored over the article, scrutinizing each face in the picture hoping to see my mother.  My mother could have been in that picture. She left her home of creature comforts and relative ease in Boston for the rigors and hardships of life in a communal setting, a well-populated flat in Haight-Ashbury.

My mother, nee Amanda, slid naturally and easily into communal living.  Like so many of her peers during the mid-1960s, my mother renounced academics and a seemingly conventional lifestyle in a seemingly conventional home in a seemingly conventional suburb of Boston.  By all accounts, my mother was the prototypical, stereotypical rebel.  She took the 1960s rebellion steps further by forming a short-lived garage band in late 1964, the only girl in the area to make this move.  She was also the only female member of that garage band.  A faded news clipping from a Boston newspaper replete with a faded photograph shows the Sun Beams, as they were known, with my mother in the foreground.  My mother was a flower child, slightly ahead of her time.  In matching and pairing up these somewhat related articles, I could all too easily see how my mother became yet another daisy in the chain who answered the siren song resonating from the West Coast.

There are places I'll remember, all my life, though some have changed Some forever, not for better, some have gone and some remain.

Never a conformist even by flower child standards, my mother did not end up in the Golden City by way of thumb, VW bus, or even Greyhound bus.  My mother was part of the New England culture she was determined to flee. She scrimped and saved by performing in smoky coffee houses (was there such a thing in those days as a coffeehouse that wasn't smoky?) and the Campus Circuit during 1964-1965.  It was during this period that she decided to catch a silver bird winging west instead of a Greyound Bus, San Francisco bound.

You fly out as your smile wears thin  
I sigh knowing the mess you're in.  
And you know that you can't get away  
And you know that you can't  
hide it from yourself  
Lonely days, blue guitar  
There's no escape, can only run so far.

What bravery, I think now.  Imagine being that resourceful at age 16 and that willing to take such a chance.  Had my mother not taken that silver bird, had not dropped out of the 11th grade despite my grandparents' many protests, threats and entreaties and promise of their 1958 Ford Fairlane, which later went to my uncle and aunt-in-law, would I be avidly reading her diary now?

Lonely nights, traveling far  
There's no escape, can only run so far.  
Lonesome tears, after the dark  
There's no escape, can only run so far.

Doubtful.  I think of that long and winding road that ultimately led to me.  My mother left Boston without a word to anyone and, according to notes in a cheap, blue-flowered diary, had the plane ticket sent to an anonymous post office box.  Sometime after 6:30 p.m. on November 19, 1965, she hitched a ride to Logan Airport with a number of students, folkhounds, Beatle fans and other artists.  There, she renamed herself Amber Rain and caught an evening plane to San Francisco, never to return to Boston alive.

***

I've always been distinctive; that is the one thing everyone who knows me can agree on.  I was born a flower child.  I took my first independent breath on Tuesday, October 18, 1966, on the heels of the Beatles' swan song concert in San Francisco, which had taken place a month and a half prior to my birth.  The name I was given, Sunrise Bluebird (because you were like a sunrise, new and beautiful, my birth was noted in the diary) further served to distinguish me.  Ironically, having such a name in San Francisco during the height of flower power was viewed as natural and commonplace. 

I was born in a small, church-run clinic a mere stone's throw from Golden Gate Park.  A group of Amber Rain's friends passed the hat around on our behalf so as to ensure that we both got proper care.  My first home was in a small crash pad on Haight, inhabited by many people.  My layette was second hand, lovingly donated by area churches and whatever my communal family could scrape up.

It would be easy for someone who was not part of this lifestyle to jump to the erroneous conclusion that my communal "relatives" were weirdo freaks and that I was deprived.  Neither was the case.  I wore the finest Salvation Army and Goodwill clothing; my communal relatives tie-dyed and put together the rest of my wardrobe.  My lullabies were the Beatles, Jefferson Airplane, Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, the Who and various street performers and many other psychedelic bands of the day.   My television was the live technicolor scenery of brightly, gaudily painted and garbed people in the neighborhood and Golden Gate Park.

The living room I played in was a grand assortment of salvaged street furniture and boxes; my play area was an inverted crate somebody had filched from a delivery truck.  "California's Finest Fruits" was emblazoned in flowing green script, with a flower dotting each i.  Very apropos, this.  I enjoyed many an outing in yet another crate - Amber Rain and my communal family had nailed two pairs of roller skates onto an apple crate and attached a paisley strap to it so I could be toted about in style. 

All of my meals were fruits and vegetables from the co-op and the church kitchen, lovingly whirred down to a liquified state on a donated blender.  My baby book was a speckled school notebook.  My developmental milestones were lovingly recorded in the hippie vernacular of the day and someone even drew a series of psychedelic hearts and flowers with the inscription, Sunrise Bluebird, may you never become corupt [sic] by ego and greed.  Stay pure like a happy bluebird on the second to last page.  I received my booster shots and check ups at the Free Clinic on 558 Clayton, which opened on June 9, 1967.  Being treated there was somewhat of an honor - I was one of the Free Clinic's first very young clients.

This information did not come from a series of memories, post hoc or otherwise.  It came from a series of photographs lovingly stored in a green album; the blue-flowered diary and an old reel-to-reel film, a note, photographs and a tape that I received by FedEx some 30 years later.

All of these items were shipped back to Boston along with me in late 1967 shortly after Amber Rain's death.  Amber Rain died, apparently from an overdose, on Friday, September 29, 1967.  Since she used my grandparents’ address on my birth certificate, my communal family was able to contact them and see that all necessary arrangements were made for them to come to San Francisco and bring me home.

It's all too much for me to see...it's all too much for me to take...

Naturally, I came as something of a shock to them.  My grandparents could not relate to the Flower Child generation and were appalled by the only home I knew.  I can well imagine the looks on their faces as they took in the vibrant posters on the walls; the macrame hammock that held flower pots containing marijuana; the street furniture and the towels that doubled as curtains.  I obviously have no conscious memory of this sudden upheaval, but I always find the accounts quite interesting.

She (what did we do that was wrong)  
is leaving (we didn't know it was wrong)  
home (Fun is the one thing money can't buy)

The place Amber Rain and I called home and the people we recognized as our family were an affront to my Boston relatives’ straitlaced sensibilities.  Even my very name caused ructions and tongue-wagging among them.  The absence of a father's name on my birth certificate caused even more speculation.  I did not know then and don't know now who my natural father was, but I think I do know some things about whoever he was.  I know he had to have had red hair and an aptitude for math.  Neither one of these traits were present among my maternal relatives in Boston.

Not knowing this really did not distinguish me among my peers.  Once all the necessary funeral and travel arrangements had been made, I was taken to Boston and raised by Amber Rain's older brother and sister-in-law, both of whom were 15 years her senior.  I was raised alongside my older cousins, with scant mention of my origins in California.  Ironicially, one tangible reminder of Amber Rain's flight was that 1958 Ford Fairlane, the very car she had turned down in favor of life in the Golden City.

This is not to say that the question of my early days never came up; for a period of time I ruthlessly plied my Boston relatives with questions.  Oh, they answered as best they could and, while not apt to criticize Amber Rain overtly, they made it quite plain that they thought eschewing a "conventional, proper New England upbringing" to "chase bohemian rainbows" as something they just could not understand.

The more I learn, the less I know...

Cryptic clues traveled east with me.  My meager belongings, along with the diary and the notebook were put away "for safe keeping" along with a piece of blue paper bearing the inscription, "The more answers you have, the more questions you'll ask.  Never let your mind go still," with a trademark signature I would not see until more than three decades had passed.

From time to time, I'd take a ribbing from my cousins or some classmate about being born a flower child.  One year somebody actually pulled up some fuzzy, half-dead dandelions and left them on my desk with a crudely-scrawled note note that read, "blow way dandelion."  This was apparently a nod to the Rolling Stones' classic, Dandelion OR a personal dig.  Since I was never in-crowd material, I opted for the latter to explain this act.  I never found out who left the dandelions or the note.

My hair color made me more conspicuous than I would have liked.  It was bright red, which does not tend to go unnoticed.  Since I knew of no other redheaded relatives, and Amber Rain's hair was a dull blonde, I could only conclude that my red hair was a paternal donation.  Rather than lament over being the lone redhead in my home, I viewed my hair as a link, a clue to my natural father.  The only common physical trait I shared with my maternal relatives was my small stature and obvious resemblance to Amber Rain.

I would often brag to my peers that I was brought up by the Beatles, Jefferson Airplane and the Who.  As a lifetime Beatles' fan, I would, in time come to see just how chillingly accurate my youthful boasts were.

My lifelong journey to uncover my origins did not end in either San Francisco or Boston.  Unlike Amber Rain, I adjusted to my life in New England, graduated on time ("the 4-year plan") and earned my degree.  Much to my grandparents' dismay, I earned my undergraduate degree from UC Berkeley and my M.A. from Stanford.  Although there was general unease over my decision to go to the West Coast, it was plain that I was heading west for reasons vastly different from Amber Rain's decades earlier.  I won't deny that curiosity and fascination with my early days motivated me to a certain extent, but that was not my sole reason for relocating to California.

Oh, I had what I thought was a mainstream life, and from all outward appearances, I did.  UC-Berkeley, with all its respelendent joys and sorrows of academic and social life; Stanford, with its very name the stamp of high accomplishment and later, a highly pleasant social life.

I had no fear of where I was treading  
I only found it out when I was down  
upon my knees  
Looking for my life.

***

A phone call.  A letter.  Sometimes both.  Either form of communication has the power to change people's lives permanently.  In my case, the latest disruption was caused by both.

My older cousin Michael and I had always shared a deep bond.  We viewed one another as siblings as opposed to cousins.  We lived on opposite coasts; he was an attorney living in Vermont and remaining comfortable in New England climes.  Since he and I had always enjoyed a close relationship, receiving a phone call from him was not at all unexpected.  Neither was the package he sent me via FedEx.  He heralded its arrival with a telephone call, letting me know it would be arriving a day before he did.

The tectonic shifts in my life came about from the contents of that package and the actual conversation that we had.  On February 4, 2005 I learned that George Harrison and I had actually met.  At one time, I actually "knew" a Beatle!

"Michael, are you sure?"  I demanded.  I didn't like tricks.

"Yeah, I'm sure. When I took that business trip to England in 2000, I had the top Beatle archivists and specialists verify and appraise this stuff.  Those documents are in the file I am about to show you.  Sunrise Bluebird, you did not come from San Francisco with a small bag of oddments.  You came back to Boston with a veritable fortune." 

This was all too much.  Me, commune born and raised?  Me actually know a Beatle?!  And my favorite Beatle at that?  If this was some kind of a trick....

It's all too much for me to see...it's all too much for me to take...

"Look, Sunrise, I know what you are thinking.  Yeah, I've been a wiseass and I like a good joke and can be a king sized pain in the ass, but I would never make this stuff up.  Did you open that package?" 

“No, I haven’t yet.” 

"Good.  I'm glad you waited.  Wait until I get there.  I will be flying into Oakland Airport on tomorrow at 7:30.  That's 10:30 East Coast time and as per my e-mail, I'll only be there until Wednesday.  I sent the package a day early because I wanted it safe with you until I got there and I don't trust those electronic scanners at the airport.  I can't wait to see you.  And," he added mischievously, "that package you are not going to open until I get there."  After engaging in some light hearted banter, I hung up and all thoughts turned to that FedEx package. 

Michael knew very good and well I wasn't going to open that package until he arrived.  Sometimes I forget we're cousins and think we really are siblings.  Michael trusts me, I kept thinking.  That was the only thing that kept me from racing to the closet and getting out that package and opening it.  I can't betray his trust.  He even had the package fully insured.

***

Saturday, February 5, 2005 was ushered in by blue birds and blue skies.  Michael and I agreed to have dinner in Chinatown and from there, drive to my home.  The FedEx package was kept in a locked safe in my closet, per Michael's instructions.

After exchanging the requisite pleasantries, we enjoyed our dinner.  After more small talk and comparing notes on our respective lives on our respective resident coasts, the discussion turned serious.  No sooner had we finished our meal, driven to my home and walked in through my front door, than the talk turned serious.

"Sunrise, please go get that package I mailed you," Michael said.  "I'll be waiting at the dining table for you.  I want to go over the contents with you and the legal ramifications involved.  Copies of what I sent you are kept in a locked safe in my office."  I had never seen my cousin so serious.

I was reduced to a quivering mass as I opened that package under Michael's falcon-eyed scrutiny.  At first glance, the contents looked harmless enough.  A cheap, green-flowered photo album.  A size-6M shoebox.  A cassette tape.  An old movie reel.  A speckled notebook, much like the ones used in classrooms.  A battered, blue-flowered diary.

Michael turned to me, all humor erased from his face.  "Yeah, it's what you think it is, Sunrise Bluebird," he said.  "Look through that album.  That was when you lived in the Haight that first year.  And the diary along with that notebook.  It all belonged to Amber Rain," he said.  "Are you ready to watch this movie?  I had three copies made.  You and I each own a copy.  The third copy is in a safe deposit box in my bank in Rutland.  All of this is yours to claim at any time, Sunrise.  It's a good thing you have an old movie projector.  You 'd make a retro museum out of a palace."

I had to laugh.  This was the one person who had always laughed at my tendency to buy retro items during my many forages to thrift stores.  "Going thrifting," I'd say.  Many is the time a smile would pass over my tendency to "go thrifting," as this was something Amber Rain and my communal family did quite often during my first year.  The faded green album showing me in my second-hand finery was testament to that fact.

"Oh, you kidder!" I said, taking a playful swipe at Michael with the 1964-1967 diary.  In so doing, I accidentally knocked the shoebox off the table, spilling its contents.  An envelope fell to the floor.  In faded blue felt-tip were scrawled the words, "Golden Gate Park, August 7, 1967," a circle of daisies surrounding the inscription. 

I bent down to retrieve the envelope.  Weakened by resting within the shoebox for more than three decades, it spilled open.  Several 3 1/2 x 3 1/2 square photographs showed George Harrison, sitting cross-legged in Golden Gate Park, his wife Pattie at his side, looking alternately happy and uncomfortable.  Amber Rain was in several of those photos too.  What I was not prepared for was seeing myself in the shots as well.  In all eight photographs, I was either sitting with George and Pattie or with Amber Rain, looking smilingly on.

My face went ashen.  "You....you....you...knew?"  I managed to drag out.

"Yes, Sunrise, I've known for some years.  When you were brought East in 1967, none of us children were told anything about this.  It is only within the past ten years that I've known, but we were all under a gag order not to say anything.  When I was named executor of our grandparents’ estate in 1993, I found out.  I wanted to tell you all along..."

I want to tell you, my head is filled with things to say.
When you're here, all those words, they seem to slip away.

I took a series of deep breaths and straightened some papers on the table.  "I can only imagine what this shock must mean for you," Michael said.  "It was a major shock to us as well.  Oh, and don't be surprised, but I've been doing some bloodhounding over the years and could never track down any of your communal relatives."

...some are dead and some are living,
in my life, I've loved them all...

I somehow managed to laugh.  "Knowing you, I am not surprised, you old bloodhound, you!  When I was at Berkeley, I would go to Haight-Ashbury and try to find the people who lived there in 1966-67, but had no luck.  How...how...how did you get all this stuff?  I need a drink!"  Not a drinker by nature, I kept a bottle of fine Napa Valley wine on hand for guests.  Now seemed the time to imbibe.

"I'll pour that," Michael said, taking it from me.  "Right now you'd flood the place if you tried.  Where are your good wine glasses?  Is that any way to treat a guest?" he said jokingly.  Mutely, I pointed to the cabinet. 

"Good.  A drink is in order.  Just sip your wine while we watch this movie.  I had it copied onto a dvd.  You and I each have a copy of that dvd.  Your copy is in that file I handed you.  I wanted you to watch it on the original reel-to-reel so you would know this was on the level."

Going into automatic pilot, I set up the projector.  There was no use pretending I was composed.  It was obvious that I was not.  The wine needed some more time to kick in.

Images filled the back wall, as I had no screen.  Images of the Summer of Love filled the space.  There was a large crowd of people George Harrison would later describe as "hideous, spotty little teenagers."  Somebody thrust a guitar into his arms.  George's heart-shaped sunglasses, beaded jewelry and psychedelic clothing helped him blend into the crowd to a certain extent.  Chameleon, I thought, watching the film.  George, wearing bright colors and a flower button in order to blend in.

There was no mistaking Amber Rain, sitting cross-legged and not even two feet from where George and Pattie were sitting.  What really caused me to spill my wine was seeing myself in that film! And with George!

It's easier to look upon someone else's wealth
than it is to see yourself.

George made a somewhat halfhearted effort to strum the guitar he was given (I had read in many articles covering that impromptu concert on Hippie Hill that the song George "played" was part of Baby, You're a Rich Man).  I, then not quite a year old, crawled over to where George and Pattie were sitting.  No doubt attracted by her bright beads, I wrapped one small fist around them and laughed.  Taking my curiosity a step further, I tugged at George's heart-shaped sunglasses.  George obliged my curiosity by taking them off and putting them on me.  Plainly this was a game to be enjoyed; I kept at it until George set me on the grass and signalled to Pattie.  The crowd began moving closer; it was plain from the looks on many faces that the festive mood had soured. 

The hippies are a good idea - love, flowers and that is great - but when you see the other half of it, it's like anything.  I love all these people, too, those who are honest and trying to find a bit of truth and to straighten out the untruths.  I'm with them 100%, but when I see the bad side of it, I'm not happy. --- George Harrison, in an interview reflecting on his San Francisco sojourn

Handing me back to Amber Rain, George and Pattie raced towards a waiting car.  Whoever shot the film caught George stuffing a piece of paper into the pocket of Amber Rain's flowered dress.  The film rolled for about another minute, ending with a shot of the Hippie Hill crowd, pursuing the fleeing couple. 

The speech of flowers excels the flowers of speech
But what's often in your heart is the hardest thing to reach  
and life is one long mystery, my friend,  
So live on, live on, the answer's at the end.

I turned to Michael.  "All this time, you've known," I said.

Michael regarded me solemnly.  "Not about the contents of that diary or the envelope," he said. "The tape of the song and the crowd and the film, yeah.  If you play the tape, you will hear the crowd at Hippie Hill that day.  I don't know who shot the film or made the tape - I can only surmise that it was any one of the people you lived with in Haight-Ashbury.  These things were lovingly and carefully packed in a box when you came to Boston.  What they did was a final act of love.  I think they knew even then how valuable this stuff was and felt it would be safe in Boston with you, its rightful owner."

It's all too much for me to take...

The contents of that FedEx package was indeed worth a fortune, but its loving value far exceeded any monetary figure.  I had actually watched, had seen Amber Rain moving; talking; laughing and with me.  Still photographs could never have given me this, this sense; this chance to see Amber Rain, my mother.  In watching the old reel-to-reel footage, I could see the source of many of my mannerisms.

The writing's on the wall...

Michael obviously shared my thoughts.  "Yes, I plainly see you in Amber Rain," he said.  "You, of all people have the right to this information.  In recent years I worked from my end to protect and preserve all of this material in toto." 

Never glimpse the truth - then it's far too late - then they pass away.

I knelt to retrieve the stack of photographs and placed them back into the envelope.  In so doing, my fingers brushed a plastic baggie.  Extracting it from the envelope, I saw a small piece of blue paper.  Removing it, I read the message, The more answers you have, the more questions you'll ask.  Never let your mind go still-George Harrison.

It was as if a vacuum had pulled all the air out of the room.  "My favorite Beatle wrote this?" I felt like California after the BIG ONE - a series of tectonic shifts and smaller after shocks.  Never, never in my wildest imaginings could I have EVER envisioned such an encounter.  Never could I have thought such a thing was even possible.  George and Pattie obviously accepted Amber Rain, me, and our extended family unconditionally and we did likewise. 

When you've seen beyond yourself  
then you may find peace of mind is  
waiting there.

Michael and I reviewed the material he had sent me.  The air was thick with expectation.  We trusted one another implicitly; we would never share knowledge of the contents of that package without consulting one another first.  My other cousins, now freed from the gag order could also be counted on to keep silent about these treasures.  Michael assured me that his siblings had neither seen the film nor heard the tape nor read the contents of the diary and notebook.  The tape was merely a cacophony of voices and music, each intertwined and indistinguishable.  Michael's explanation jibed with my lifelong recollections - that this box of worldly possessions had traveled across country with me in 1967, not to be opened until a minimum of 30 years had passed.  Only the most basic and general answers were given during that long interim period and no amount of pleading and cajoling on my part granted me access to that box.  Now, after more than three decades had passed, there was no viable way of locating or contacting the people I knew during my Haight-Ashbury period of 1966-67; my grandparents had named Michael as their executor together with the proviso that he deliver this information and package to me and me alone.

***

In thinking it over, I've come to the conclusion that was probably the best decision all around.  How disruptive to the lives of many people, my favorite Beatle included, this would be had it come out.  Newshounds would have dogged me; privacy would be sorely compromised.  As distinctive as the name Sunrise Bluebird was, the one thing I didn't need was to make myself even more so.  Michael was in full accord.  During the week he spent in California, we reached a compromise - we would share this information with only those whom we trusted most and at no time would we disclose anything without informing the other.

***

When Michael returned to Vermont on February 9, 2005, we continued as always to keep one another appraised on milestones and events in each other's lives.  Not a week passed when we failed to e-mail each other or some other relatives.  It was during his first week back in Vermont that we agreed to inform the Powers That Be at the Fest For Beatle Fans.

In late February, I received an e-mail from Michael together with a double attachment.  The first attachment was an e-mail he had received from the Fest For Beatle Fans, requesting our presence as guests to talk about our story. Careful assurances were made that nothing beyond sharing our story would be asked of us; at no time would any profits be made from the "Summer of Love" story.  All proceeds, per our direction would go to the Harrisons' Charity of Choice and every step would be taken to respect their wishes.

Well and good, I e-mailed back.  The clincher was how the 'Fest kindly offered to cover our travel expenses and recognize us as guest speakers.  As soon as I had sent Michael that reply, I checked the second attachment.  The second e-mail came from George's sister, Lou, with a request.

I turned back to my laptop and sent in a "reply all" e-mail my answer, which was a resounding yes.  My answer was at the end.

Copyright 2005, Lisa N. Collins

About the Author

Lisa N. Collins has been writing short stories since age 7 and is a lifelong Beatles' fan.  She has been a Beatleologist since age 12.  A late talker and early reader, she has been largely influenced by the Beatles.  She has worked in advertising and editing and is currently a freelancer.  She says that the best thing about writing stories is that like a ventriloquist, one can throw their voice around and create different characters and personalities.

Tell Lisa Collins what you thought of her story!

Return to Rooftop Sessions Current Issue

Return to Rooftop Sessions Archive